By Lustitia Aequalis
When Jabari Peoples was shot in the back by a Homewood police officer, his family asked one thing: show us the video.
He was 18, a recent high school graduate with plans to study criminal justice. On June 23, he was sitting in a parked car outside a soccer complex when an officer approached. Minutes later, Jabari was dying. Police say he grabbed a gun. His family says he didn’t. But there’s body-camera footage—footage that could clarify what happened. And still, nearly two months later, it hasn’t been fully released.
Why? Because in Alabama, a 2023 law meant to improve access to police body-camera footage contains a legal loophole wide enough to bury the truth.
🎥 A Law Meant for Transparency, Twisted by Loopholes
Alabama Act 2023-507 was supposed to create a clear path for families to view body-camera recordings when a loved one is harmed or killed by police. It allows footage to be requested by a “personal representative,” like a parent or attorney.
But the law also gives law enforcement broad power to deny that request if disclosure “would affect an ongoing investigation or prosecution.” And that’s exactly the exemption the Alabama Law Enforcement Agency (ALEA) cited when it refused the Peoples family access to the full video for weeks, according to AP News.
When they finally did get a viewing, the clip was brief. Three of the four minutes were reportedly dead space. The actual confrontation was edited, according to civil rights attorney Ben Crump, who noted that key context and angles were left out.
District Attorney Danny Carr ultimately declined to file charges, calling the shooting “justified.” But Jabari’s family and legal team say the investigation never included full transparency.
⚖️ What the Law Says—And What It Doesn’t
Here’s how Alabama Act 2023-507 works—and why it’s failing the very people it was supposed to help:
What it allows: Families of people involved in a police encounter can formally request to view body-camera footage.
What it protects: Law enforcement can decline if they believe sharing the video would interfere with an active investigation or prosecution.
What it doesn’t do: Set clear timelines for release, define “relevance,” or require full and unedited access.
Rep. Juandalynn Givan, who authored the bill, has acknowledged its flaws and introduced amendments to close the gap—including a six-month deadline for footage disclosure. So far, none have passed. As reported by the Washington Post, she worked with police unions to narrow the bill’s scope just to get it passed.
Meanwhile, families like the Peoples are left in the dark.
🧩 When Legal Doesn’t Mean Just
Across the country, body-camera footage was pitched as a check on power. A window into the truth. But without firm legal standards, police departments have too much discretion—and too little accountability.
In Colorado, a judge recently ordered footage released despite law enforcement objections.
In California, a state appeals court ruled that ongoing investigations weren’t a valid reason to deny footage.
But in Alabama, and in many other states, “transparency” still hinges on the willingness of police to cooperate.
Jabari’s case isn’t isolated. In 2024, the family of Phillip Reeder waited nearly a year to access footage of his fatal encounter with Irondale police. And unless legal reform catches up, more families will face the same delay tactics cloaked in legal language.
🔒 Trust Requires Truth—And Timelines
The refusal to release body-cam footage doesn’t just delay closure. It deepens community distrust. As Jabari’s sister, Angel Smith, said after viewing the short video: “My brother was afraid. He was running for his life.”
The law was written with a door. But too many departments are using that door to block grieving families instead of opening it.
📱 How the Witness App Protects What the Law Delays
When your rights depend on someone else’s timeline, you need a tool that works in real time.
The Witness App helps you do what the system often won’t: capture, store, and protect critical footage—on your terms. It activates instantly, backs up to the cloud, and time-stamps your recording. No edits. No excuses. No months of waiting while agencies “review” what should be public.
In places where body-camera footage can be withheld, your own recording may be the only full account. Don’t leave the truth in someone else’s hands.
Download the Witness App. Practice using it. Protect yourself before they claim there’s nothing to show.